Home » Articles » Hebert

Voices: Hebert

Open I/O Systems Arrive

Automation Pros Like You Use Digital I/O Networks as the Wedge to Pry Apart Proprietary Controller-I/O Bonds Created by Automation Vendors

ControlDesign.com

By Dan Hebert, PE, Senior Technical Editor

As a machine or robot-building automation professional, you’ve been hearing about open systems for years. But you probably have been frustrated if you tried to create an open automation system using components from competing vendors.

However, it looks like the worm is turning as automation pros like you use digital I/O networks as the wedge to pry apart proprietary controller-I/O bonds created by automation vendors.

Digital I/O networks were created by automation vendors to answer customer demands for reduced wiring, faster troubleshooting and easier modifications. Automation vendors made money because their more expensive digital products replaced discrete and analog components. Customers made money by taking advantage of the aforementioned benefits.

Vendors that make just one or two components of an automation system love open systems. For example, a vendor that primarily makes I/O wants one industry-wide interface between all controllers and all I/O.

Despite what they say in public, some vendors that make a wide range of automation products don’t like open systems. These vendors want to lock their customers into buying every possible automation component from them, and open systems are the enemy of that vision.

Vendors jumped on the digital I/O bandwagon for competitive reasons, and many initially did so by creating proprietary digital links. But competitive pressures forced them to adopt standard links, in particular Ethernet-based protocols. Doing this let the proprietary cat out of the bag and released the dogs of open I/O systems in pursuit.

In the bad old days, all controller I/O was local and plugged into the backplane or was connected by a short-range parallel cable. When remote I/O first was introduced, it was available only on higher-end controllers. I distinctly remember having to spend thousands more for a high-end, very-expensive PLC back in the late ’80s just to get remote I/O.

All remote I/O was connected by proprietary links and had to be purchased from the controller vendor. In the past few years, many PLC vendors have adopted Ethernet for communications between controllers and I/O. This has opened the door to true open systems where a controller from one vendor can be used easily with I/O from another.

An example of this is when Allen-Bradley PLCs are used with Opto 22 I/O. “Because our I/O natively supports EtherNet/IP, engineers can incorporate advanced I/O functionality into their A-B systems without worrying about communication, compatibility issues or extra programming,” says Tom Edwards, senior technical advisor at Opto 22.

Why would you do this rather than just use A-B I/O? According to Opto 22, the reason is intelligence. “Our Snap I/O has its own processor to handle time-critical or repetitive tasks like high-speed counting, input latching and PID loop control,” explains Edwards. “These tasks and many more are performed at the I/O level without programming.”

PLC vendors can provide some of this functionality, but, continues Edwards, “processing takes place centrally in the PLC. With our remote distributed I/O over EtherNet/IP, time-sensitive, processor-intensive tasks are off-loaded from the PLC, improving performance and keeping scan rates fast..”

Opto 22 claims that intelligence is the main reason why some builders use their I/O with Allen-Bradley processors. But there are many other reasons why industrial OEMs want to mix and match controllers and I/O.
First among them is to use best-of-breed components. No single vendor makes a controller-I/O combination best for all applications, so separating controller and I/O vendors gives machine builders more options to find the best products for their particular needs.

A second reason is cost. If an OEM is free to buy I/O from any vendor for the preferred controller, then I/O cost is driven down across the board.

A third reason is vendor preferences of the OEM’s own customers. Many customers specify the brand of controller because they don’t want to support controller programming across many different brands. But more passive components like I/O need less support and often are not specified. This can allow an OEM to save time and money by using one brand of I/O while adhering to customer controller specs.

---

More Voices

Open I/O Systems Arrive
11/10/2008
Automation Pros Like You Use Digital I/O Networks as the Wedge to Pry Apart Proprietary Controller-I/O Bonds Created by Automation Vendors

A Tale of Two Economies
09/16/2008
Manufacturing Soars as Residential and Financial Markets Plummet

Follow the Money to Find the Truth
09/03/2008
Can Anyone Be Surprised That Virtually All Government Studies, Both Direct and Funded, Conclude That Global Warming Is Indeed Occurring and Will Be a Huge Catastrophe if Something Is Not Done?

Science Fair Gives Second Chance
07/08/2008
Maker Faire Is an Adult Science and Technology Fair for the Entire Family

Automation Causes Job Destruction
06/30/2008
We Automation Professionals First Laid Waste to Employment in the Agricultural Sector Worldwide Through Automation, and We Now Have Manufacturing in Our Cross Hairs

Why Machine Builders Sell Services
05/09/2008
Comparing Product Sales to Services from a Machine Builder’s Perspective

Products Versus Services
04/18/2008
System Integrators Get Most of Their Revenue From Services, but Many Develop and Sell Products as Discrete and Somewhat Standard Items

Don’t Let the Media Get You Down
03/04/2008
For Every Apocalyptic Vision of the Future, Why Isn’t There a Movie Depicting a Much More Likely and Dramatically Better Future?

Don’t Fall for Green Technology Hoax
02/08/2008
Wind Can’t Be Relied On for Base Loads, and Wind Velocity Often Varies Inversely With Peak Power Needs

Get Others to See It Your Way
01/02/2008
Never Voice Your Opinion First. Let Someone Else Voice Your Idea. Then Agree with It. You Will Have an Instant Ally

Prime Time for OPC-UA?
12/05/2007
Big names are on board with service-oriented architecture (SOA) and OPC-UA, and no one company is seen as their creator, owner or chief proponent.

Peers and SIs Are Good Sources
10/31/2007
Writers and teachers can point you in the right direction, but they almost never are the experts when it comes to machine automation.

10 Years of Remote Support
10/03/2007
Remote support and monitoring is the one area of machine control that has benefited the most from the Internet over the past decade.

Women Too Wise to Be CEOs
09/07/2007
Is there a glass ceiling in manufacturing, especially in machine building? Few women are seen across this field, and even fewer are present at the executive level.

Fieldbus in Hazardous Areas
08/22/2007
The introduction of digital fieldbus communication networks created a number of new options for installing fieldbus devices in hazardous areas by simplifying implementation of intrinsic safety (IS) systems, thus avoiding the tried-and-true solution of explosion-proof enclosures conduit systems.

HMIs at AutomationXchange
08/01/2007
AutomationXchange gives machine builders a chance to share best practices with one another, our latest discussion was centered around human-machine interface (HMI) software. read more on the subject here.

Discrete and Process Safety Networks
07/19/2007
Right now, the needs are different and so are the means. Can one network eventually do it all?

Out of the pantry
06/06/2007
It might seem wise to buy the cheapest packaging machine available, but you don’t have to be an expert in the nuances of machine automation to know it can make the difference in purchasing decisions.

ePaper is coming
05/10/2007
In this installment of Machine Builder Mojo, Senior Tech Editor Dan Hebert, PE, says that although eBook devices are fairly new, it’s easy to envision a future in which we use them as readily as e-mail.

Does technology drive inequality?
04/04/2007
The worldwide demand for manufactured goods can’t match the growth in productivity. Manufacturing employment and the middle-class jobs associated with it inevitably must decline.

Become your own brand
03/05/2007
The days of lifetime employment at one company are gone, notes Senior Tech Editor Dan Heber, PE, so it's up to you to maintain your value in the marketplace by strengthening your personal professional brand.

Less staff = More leverage for you
02/01/2007
A good strategy starts with knowing your worth in the marketplace. Keep your resumé up to date, periodically search for a new job, and establish your value. Only then can you get your employer to see the light.

Who exactly is an innovator?
01/03/2007
Real innovation depends on more than just inventions and patents and really doesn’t happen until it is put to productive use by an end customer. This puts the U.S. in the lead because it’s the best at commercializing innovation.

Less math = better engineers
11/06/2006
More free electives equals more free time equals more socialization equals engineers with much better people skills. It’s amazing that engineering deans cannot comprehend such a simple equation.

Outsourced engineering, Part II
10/10/2006
Is executing the design, startup, and support for your control, instrumentation, and electrical systems with internal resources always the right approach? Find out in this month’s installment of Machine Builder Mojo.

Outsource your engineering?
09/12/2006
Is executing the design, startup, and support for your control, instrumentation, and electrical systems with internal resources always the right approach? Find out in this month’s installment of Machine Builder Mojo.

Tale of the long tail
06/01/2006
The classic long-tail market for machine building shows that when the costs of product design, marketing, technical support, and distribution fall, then a wide range of substitute, niche products become available.

You must comply with compliance standards
05/03/2006
Machine builders selling outside of the U.S. and Canada must comply with the same general component usage, assembly, and panel sticker requirements. However, finding information and services can be difficult.

When a game is more than a game
03/02/2006
Networking systems that allow thousands of gamers to simultaneously interact via the Internet might be scaled down and adapted to collaborative engineering, design, and machine troubleshooting.

Write for a living?
02/08/2006
Senior Tech Editor Dan Hebert, PE, waited 22 years before deciding that teaching and writing was the best answer to his career woes. If you can afford the likely pay cut, you might want to look into it, too.

Machine builders take over the controls
01/12/2006
Show your customers how giving you the freedom to specify machine control systems will improve their plant operations through better performance, less downtime, and reduced maintenance costs.

Secrets to improving machine performance
11/03/2005
Control Design has created an event that significantly facilitates peer-to-peer interaction and promotes important conversation among machine builders, and we invite you to participate as our guests.

Right connection is no optical illusion
10/27/2005
Senior Tech Editor Dan Hebert, PE, ponders what the future may bring to advances in fiberoptic connectors that allows a single connector and cable to power and control remote applications.

Compete with Chinese labor? Yes you can
09/01/2005
Senior Technical Editor Dan Hebert, PE, says the threat from cheap Chinese labor is exaggerated by the popular press because, like sex and money, fear and paranoia sell.

Are you being served at user group meetings?
07/17/2005
User group meetings are not going away, but Senior Technical Editor Dan Hebert is speaking out on your behalf to encourage vendors to migrate back to the roots of user group meetings.

McMachines, Thousands Sold
06/15/2005
Branding usually isn’t seen as a function of technical professionals, but it is the most important component to demonstrating the performance advantages of your machines. Senior Tech Editor Dan Hebert, PE, explains in this month's edition of Machine Builder Mojo.

Can a technical engineer make it in Prime Time?
05/01/2005
Senior Technical Editor Dan Hebert is sharpening up his acting skills for his big shot at Prime Time television in this month's edition of Machine Builder Mojo. But does he have the charisma it takes to pull it off?

Real Time Becomes Future Time
08/12/2003
There are several trends in the commercial OS market that will affect industrial machine control systems; chief among them is distributed computing